Christianity in post-war Ukraine: challenges, trends, cautions. “Theology after Bucha”
Abstract
The article is almost the first scientific study of Christianity in Ukraine within the period of the current Russian-Ukrainian war in Ukrainian academic religious studies. The author outlines possible conditions for the appearance of a new theological system in Ukrainian Christianity after the victory over Rashism, following the example of the one that started in Western Christianity after World War II. At the same time, the article reveals a number of cautions that can, if not responded to these days, make the constructive development of this theology impossible.
References
“Ukrainian "Never Again" vs. Russian "Let's Repeat"” [“Ukrainske “Nikoly znovu” proty rosiiskoho “Mozhem povtorit””], Glavcom. May 8, 2023, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://glavcom.ua/columns/epifaniy/ukrajinske-nikoli-znovu-proti-rosijskoho-mozhem-povtorit-925555.html [in Ukrainian]
“Bucha: Where was God and is He at all” [“Bucha: De buv Boh i chy ye Vin vzahali”], RISU – Religious Information Service of Ukraine. 04.04.2022, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://risu.ua/bucha-de-buv-bog-i-chi-ye-vin-vzagali_n127979 [in Ukrainian]
“The Pope compared the war of the Russian Federation against Ukraine with the Nazi "Operation Reinhardt"” [“Papa Rymskyi porivniav viinu rf proty Ukrainy z natsystskoiu “operatsiieiu Reinhard””], Ukrinform, 07.12.2022, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-uarazom/3629525-papa-rimskij-porivnav-vijnu-rf-proti-ukraini-z-nacistskou-operacieu-rejngard.html [in Ukrainian]
“Pope: one should not play with the martyrdom of the Ukrainian people” [“Papa: ne slid hratysia z muchenytstvom ukrainskoho narodu”], CREDO, September 24, 2023, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://credo.pro/2023/09/356179 [in Ukrainian]
“The Holocaust is not a punishment, the Almighty is not a sadist” [“Kholokost – ne nakazanie, Vsevyshnii – ne sadist”], Hadashot news of Jewish life in Ukraine, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: http://archive.hadashot.kiev.ua/content/holokost-ne-nakazanie-vsevyshniy-ne-sadist [in Russian]
“Why didn't G-d destroy evil in the bud? – questions for the rabbi” [“Pochemu B-g ne unichtozhil zlo v zarodyshe? – voprosy ravvinu”], Judaism and Jews on Toldot.ru, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://toldot.com/urava/ask/urava_11640.html [in Russian]
“Why did the Creator, being self-sufficient, decide to create the world? – questions for the rabbi” [“Pochemu Tvorets, buduchi samodostatochnym, reshil sozdat' mir? – voprosy ravvinu”], Judaism and Jews on Toldot.ru, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://toldot.com/urava/ask/urava_4942.html [in Russian]
“Hiding the Creator”, Encyclopedia of Judaism online at Toldot.ru, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://toldot.com/sokritie.html [in Russian]
“What did the Rebbe say (and what did he not say) about the Holocaust?” [“Chto Rebe govoril (i chego on ne govoril) o Kholokoste?”], Kharkov Holocaust Museum (Digest E). 2016, May, No. 5 (203), viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: http://holocaustmuseum.kharkov.ua/didgest-e/didgest-2016/05-2016/index.html [in Russian]
“Who is to blame for the Holocaust? – questions for the rabbi” [“Kto vinoven v Kholokoste? – voprosy ravvinu”], Judaism and Jews on Toldot.ru, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://toldot.com/urava/ask/urava_1920.html [in Russian]
Vikhrov, M. (2022), “Theology after Buchi” [“Teolohiia pislia Buchi”], Verbum, April 27, 2022, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://www.verbum.com.ua/04/2022/gold-on-blue/theology-after-bucha/
Soloviy, R. (2022), “Theology after Buchi” [“Teolohiia pislia Buchi]”, April 3, 2022. Facebook, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://www.facebook.com/731114482/posts/10159902126439483/ [in Ukrainian]
Zahrebel’nyi, I. (2022), “Do we need a "new theology after Buchi"” [“Chy potribna nam “nova teolohiia pislia Buchi””], Political theology, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://politteo.online/materialy/chy-potribna-nam-nova-teologiya-pislya-buchi/ [in Ukrainian]
“Life is unfair. God is still good” [“Zhyttia nespravedlyve. Boh, yak i ranishe, dobryi”], For the evangelical faith, No. 8 (258), August 2023. P. 1. [in Ukrainian]
“Spiritual reasons for Russia's war against Ukraine From Andrew the First-Called to Volodymyr the Great” [“Dukhovni prychyny viiny rosii proty Ukrainy Vid Andriia Pervozvannoho do Volodymyra Velykoho”], For the evangelical faith, No. 8 (258), August 2023, pp. 3-5 [in Ukrainian]
“Let not your heart be troubled” [“Khai vashe sertse ne tryvozhytsia”], For the evangelical faith, No. 1 (251), January 2023 [in Ukrainian]
Volkovsky, V., Samchuk, R. (2023), “Is "Philosophy After Buchi" Possible: The Contribution of War to Philosophy” [“Chy mozhlyva “filosofiia pislia Buchi”: vnesok viiny v filosofiiu”], Philosophy of education, No. 29 (1), pp. 22-51 [in Ukrainian]
“How the legendary religious scholar Ihor Kozlovsky answered questions about the war” [“Yak lehendarnyi relihiieznavets Ihor Kozlovskyi vidpovidav na pytannia pro viinu”], TSN, 12.09.23, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: https://tsn.ua/other/bog-ne-potrebuye-nashogo-vipravdannya-yak-legendarniy-religiyeznavec-igor-kozlovskiy-vidpovidav-na-pitannya-pro-viynu-2408416.html [in Ukrainian]
Jonas, H. (1987), Der Gottesbegriff nach Auschwitz: eine jüdische Stimme, Suhrkamp, Frankfurt/Main, Verlag, 64 s. [in German]
Jonas, H. (1996), Mortality and Morality: A Search for Good After Auschwitz, Northwestern University Press, Evanston, 218 p.
Kalyna, O. (2022), “Why did God allow war in Ukraine?” [“Chomu Boh dopustyv viinu v Ukraini?”], House of the Gospel Church. Friday, August 26, 2022, viewed 14 Maу 2024, available at: http://baptist.vn.ua/blog/item/14-chomu-v-ukraini-viina [in Ukrainian]
Levinas, E. (2000), Favorites. Totality and the Infinite [Izbrannoe. Total'nost' i Beskonechnoe], University book, Moscow, SPb.,. 416 p. [in Russian]
Frankl, W. (1990), “Man's Search for Meaning” [“Chelovek v poiskakh smysla”]. Collection: Trans. from English and German / General ed. L. Ya. Gozman and D. A. Leontyev; introd. article D. A. Leontyev, Moscow, Progress. 368 pp. [in Russian]
Adorno, T. (2019), “Education after Auschwitz” [“Vykhovannia pislia Aushvitsa”], Philosophy of education, No. 2 (25), pp. 82-99. [in Ukrainian]
Adorno, T. W. (2003), “After Auschwitz” [“Posle Osventsima”], Adorno T. V. Negative dialectics / Trans. E. L. Petrenko, Scientific world, Moscow, pp. 322-325 [in Russian]
Fackenheim, E. (1994), “About Christianity after the Holocaust” [“O khristianstve posle Golokausta”], The socio-political dimension of Christianity. Selected theological texts of the 20th century (Translations) / Comp. S. V. Lezov and O. V. Borovoy. Enter S. V. Lezov, Science. Publishing company "Oriental Literature", Moscow, 406 p. [in Russian]
